Despite having a less convoluted birth canal, Neandertals felt the difficult pangs of childbirth just like modern humans do, according to a recent study of a female Neandertal pelvis unearthed in Israel more than 70 years ago.
Unlike our ape and monkey relatives, human babies are about the same size as the birth canal, making for a “difficult” passage, the two male authors write. (How’s that for an understatement?)
In fact, the human birth canal is twisted, wider than it is long in some places, and longer than it is wide in others. This means that babies must twist as they make their egress: entering the birth canal sideways, the baby must rotate so its head is down, and then rotate again to allow its shoulders to pass.
When did the ape’s birth canal evolve into the twisted, and painful, human version? Timothy Weaver and Jean-Jacques Hublin used CT scans to reconstruct a birth canal from pelvic bone fossil fragments from a Neandertal and compared this to data from pelvic bones from modern humans.
Weaver and Hublin’s reconstruction suggest that the Neandertal’s birth canal was less twisted than that of modern humans. But the pelvic area in Neandertals and modern humans is similar, suggesting that even though Neandertal babies didn’t have to twist as much during delivery, their size relative to the birth canal was close enough to insure a painful passage.
The results mean that changes in childbirth probably occurred “quite late in human evolution, during the last few hundred thousand years.”
A word of caution - this type of research relies on intact fossils. The pelvis survives very poorly, which is why scientists must rely on sophisticated reconstruction techniques. The current study is based on bone from a single Neandertal, making it difficult to take normal variations present within a species into account.
You know the cliché that science knows no borders? The current study was written by a scientist in the United States and one in Germany - examining a specimen discovered in Israel by a British archaeologist - using imaging technology developed by scientists from South Africa and the United Kingdom (one of whom worked in the United States).
Source: “Neandertal birth canal shape and the evolution of human childbirth” by Timothy D. Weaver and Jean-Jacques Hublin published April 20 online in PNAS (doi: 10.1073/pnas.0812554106).





Why would a promising young scientist leave the lab to spend a year working for the United States government? Daniel Gorelick is here at the State Department trying to figure that out.