Amidst the vast variety of religious identities claimed by Americans, one label just doesn’t seem to sit well–atheism. In national surveys–including large samples of the American population taken in 2001 and 2007–very few people claim not to believe in a god or some divine power. It’s usually no more than 1 percent who so describe themselves. And the proportion would be even smaller when it comes to people who seek a public role in political life.
Other surveys–the ones that probe Americans’ opinions about religion and politics–typically find an outright majority of Americans say they would never vote for an atheist. There’s nothing particularly new about that: Indeed, it was our first president, George Washington, who once said that personal religious belief was an essential if individuals were to possess the “virtue” necessary to govern themselves in a republic. Ever since, it has been exceptionally rare for any politician to assert that he or she lacks some form of religious identity. Doing so would be the equivalent of swallowing political poison.
And because of that, it’s rare to hear of a candidate being called an atheist, even by his or her opponent. That’s not to say it can’t happen. Throughout his campaign for the White House in 1800, Thomas Jefferson was repeatedly accused of being an “infidel” by supporters of his opponent, John Adams, then the incumbent president who had strong backing from New England’s clergy. Jefferson won; still, the calumny he endured stung him personally.
This week, another politician found herself accused of atheism, this time in the hard-fought contest for a U.S. Senate seat in North Carolina. The incumbent, Republican Elizabeth Dole, unleashed a television advertisement against her Democratic challenger, State Senator Kay Hagan, accusing her of having ties to an organization called “Godless Americans.” Hagan took the charge seriously enough to strike back hard on two fronts. She put out her own commercial, unequivocally stating that she believed in God and had taught Sunday School. And she also took the matter to court, filing a defamation suit against Dole.
It may help to know here that North Carolina has long been considered part of America’s Bible Belt, where evangelical Protestantism is dominant and religious belief and practice is widely considered even more important than in other regions. Is it a place where an accusation of a weak or non-existent religious belief could pass unchallenged in politics? As Hagan has shown, the answer is emphatically no.